openai vs. deepseek

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready…

You said:

explain this in layman’s language

ChatGPT said:

​

You said:

explain this in layman’s language

ChatGPT said:

The images you provided show comparisons of classical mechanics (Hamiltonian, Lagrangian, Newtonian equations) and quantum mechanics (Schrödinger equation). Here’s a simplified explanation:

Classical Mechanics (Top Part):

• Newtonian Mechanics (F = ma):
  • This is the most familiar form of physics. It states that force equals mass times acceleration. It’s good for everyday objects, like cars or balls.
• Hamiltonian (H = T + V):
  • Combines kinetic energy (T: energy of motion) and potential energy (V: energy of position or stored energy).
  • It describes how energy changes or stays constant over time.
• Lagrangian (L = T – V):
  • Also uses kinetic and potential energies but subtracts them. It’s just another way to represent the motion mathematically and is useful because it simplifies many complicated systems, especially those with constraints (like a pendulum).

Quantum Mechanics (Bottom Part, Schrödinger Equation):

• Classical mechanics deals with definite positions, speeds, and energies. Quantum mechanics, however, deals with probabilities.
• Schrödinger Equation (HΨ = EΨ):
  • Ψ (Psi) is called the “wavefunction.” It describes the quantum state of a particle and tells you the likelihood (probability) of finding a particle at a certain location and state.
  • Instead of exact results, quantum mechanics gives you probabilities of different outcomes.
  • The “Hamiltonian operator” (H) is just a quantum version of energy that, when used on the wavefunction, tells you what possible energies the particle could have. The actual energies a quantum system can have are “quantized,” meaning only certain discrete values are allowed.

Simple analogy:

Imagine a ball connected to a spring. In classical mechanics, you know exactly how fast it’s moving and where it is. Quantum mechanics treats particles like waves: instead of knowing exactly where the ball (particle) is, you have a wave (wavefunction) describing a range of places it could be. Solving Schrödinger’s equation gives you a detailed map of these probabilities.

In short, classical physics is exact and deterministic (clear outcomes), while quantum physics is probabilistic, dealing with chances and uncertainties.

Deepseek:

explain this in layman’s language

Thought for 14 seconds

Okay, I need to explain the content of the provided file in layman’s terms. Let’s start by breaking down the sections.

First, there’s a table comparing Hamiltonian, Lagrangian, and Newtonian equations. The user mentioned layman’s language, so I should avoid technical jargon. Let me recall: Hamiltonian is total energy (KE + PE), Lagrangian is KE – PE, and Newtonian is F=ma. The table shows different forms of these for a harmonic oscillator example, maybe a spring system. The equations involve terms like mv² and kx², which are kinetic and potential energy expressions.

Then there’s the Schrödinger equation section. It relates to quantum mechanics, replacing classical equations. The key point is that in quantum mechanics, physical quantities become operators. For example, momentum p becomes an operator involving Planck’s constant and derivatives. The Schrödinger equation uses the Hamiltonian operator to describe how the wavefunction evolves over time. The wavefunction gives probabilities of finding a particle in certain states.

I need to make sure I connect the classical concepts (like energy conservation, F=ma) to their quantum counterparts. Emphasize that while classical physics predicts exact outcomes, quantum mechanics deals with probabilities. Also, mention that operators are like mathematical tools that act on the wavefunction instead of regular numbers.

Check if I’m missing any key points from the tables. The harmonic oscillator example is used in both classical and quantum contexts. The transition from classical energy expressions to Hamiltonian operators is crucial. Also, the note about variables becoming operators, like p → ħ/(i∂x), which might need simplification.

Avoid equations as much as possible, but if necessary, explain them in simple terms. Ensure that each section (Hamiltonian/Lagrangian vs. Newtonian, then Schrödinger equation) is covered clearly. Use analogies if possible. For instance, the Hamiltonian is like the total energy budget, while the Lagrangian is the difference that helps in figuring out the path a system takes.

Finally, summarize how the Schrödinger equation is the quantum version of Newton’s laws, predicting probabilities instead of certainties. Highlight the role of the wavefunction and how measurements are distributions rather than fixed values.

Here’s a simple explanation:

Classical Physics (Newton, Hamiltonian, Lagrangian):

• Newton’s “F = ma”: Think of pushing a shopping cart. The harder you push (force), the more it accelerates. If a spring is attached, the force also depends on how stretched it is (like “F = -kx”).
• Energy View:
  • Hamiltonian (H): Total energy = kinetic (energy of motion) + potential (stored energy, like in a spring).
  • Lagrangian (L): A “useful difference” = kinetic energy – potential energy. It helps physicists predict how objects move over time.

Example: For a mass on a spring, kinetic energy is from speed (12mv221​mv2), and potential energy is from the spring’s stretch (12kx221​kx2).

---

Quantum Physics (Schrödinger Equation):

• No Certainty, Only Probabilities: Unlike classical physics (which predicts exact motion), quantum mechanics tells you the probability of where a particle (like an electron) might be.
• Wavefunctions: Particles act like waves. The Schrödinger equation describes how these “probability waves” change over time.
• Operators: Physical quantities (like momentum, pp) turn into math tools called operators. For example:
  • Momentum (pp) becomes ℏi∂∂xiℏ​∂x∂​ (a rule involving derivatives and Planck’s constant, ℏℏ).
  • The Hamiltonian becomes an operator too, combining kinetic and potential energy.

Example: For a quantum spring (harmonic oscillator), the Schrödinger equation uses these operators to calculate allowed energy levels and the wavefunction’s shape.

---

Key Takeaway:

Classical physics (Newton/Hamiltonian) works for everyday objects (cars, springs). Quantum physics (Schrödinger) rules the tiny world (electrons, atoms), where probabilities and wave-like behavior replace certainty. The Schrödinger equation is the “quantum F = ma”—it’s the recipe for predicting how quantum systems evolve.