Getting your Trinity Audio player ready…

Exploring the Emergence of Complexity in Molecular Systems

Abstract

The traditional narrative of evolution—steered by random mutation and natural selection—paints a picture of life as an accidental byproduct of chance. Yet, the extraordinary order observed in molecular machines like ATP synthase challenges this view by hinting at an inherent directional drive. Recent developments in non‐equilibrium thermodynamics and information theory suggest that the emergence of low-entropy, high-information structures may be less accidental than previously thought. Influential ideas such as Jeremy England’s work propose that under the right thermodynamic conditions, matter naturally organizes itself to more efficiently dissipate energy—thereby promoting order out of chaos. This paper explores the hypothesis that such thermodynamic inevitabilities, when coupled with the dynamics of information, imply a form of “directed complexity” in evolution. By examining ATP synthase as a paradigmatic example, we discuss how its exquisite efficiency and conserved structure may be interpreted not solely as the outcome of random chance and successive adaptations, but also as evidence of an underlying teleology. We review theoretical foundations in information dynamics, present insights from non‐equilibrium systems, and address philosophical implications. Ultimately, this study argues that while not invoking an external designer, the inherent physical laws guiding energy dissipation and information flow might well serve as a natural “agency” that directs the emergence of complexity in biological systems.

Introduction

For decades, the debate surrounding the origins of complex biological systems has oscillated between strictly mechanistic interpretations and teleological perspectives, which imply a directional force beyond blind chance. The case of molecular machines, such as ATP synthase, has become a touchstone in this debate. ATP synthase stands as one of the most elegantly efficient engines in the biological realm: a rotary molecular motor that produces the energy currency of the cell (ATP) with extreme finesse. Yet, its highly ordered structure appears to reside in a “low entropy” niche of a vast mutational space—a finding that has led some scholars to argue for an inherent directionality or teleology in evolution.

At its core, teleology refers to the idea that processes or systems are directed toward a goal or an end state. Traditional Darwinian evolution, however, contends that all biological traits arise primarily through stochastic events—namely, random mutations followed by selection pressures favoring those rare advantageous adaptations. On this view, complexity is an emergent property stemming from an immense and mostly blind process of trial and error. But if we scrutinize the emergence of complex structures like ATP synthase, we encounter a puzzle: How did an assembly of interdependent and extremely precise subunits manage to form when any single change could render the system entirely nonfunctional? This conundrum has led some to consider whether natural processes possess an inherent propensity toward the emergence of order—a “natural teleology”—imbued by the fundamental laws of physics rather than by naive randomness.

Recent advances in non-equilibrium thermodynamics and information theory offer a framework for reconsidering this dilemma. Jeremy England and others have shown that when matter is driven far from equilibrium, as it is in living systems, there is a natural tendency for self-organization. In other words, under constant energy flux and specific environmental conditions, systems may spontaneously arrange themselves into configurations that are statistically more probable because they more effectively dissipate energy. This thermodynamic drive provides one possible explanation for why life might not be purely accidental, but rather, emerges as a natural consequence of the inherent physical properties of matter.

Information dynamics enters the discussion in a similarly intriguing way. Biological systems are, fundamentally, information processors. DNA serves as the storage medium for life’s instructions, and the evolution of complex systems can be understood as a process of accruing, transmitting, and refining information over time. The concept of entropy—originally a measure of disorder in physical systems—has been reinterpreted in information theory as a measure of uncertainty or lack of information. Therefore, the sustained generation of low-entropy, high-information structures (such as ATP synthase) within a milieu characterized by overwhelming randomness raises provocative questions. Could it be that the laws governing energy dissipation and information processing predispose the emergence of such refined structures?

This paper will explore the interplay between information dynamics, thermodynamics, and evolutionary biology. It will assess whether the emergence of complex systems, particularly ATP synthase, can be seen as evidence of a more general teleological tendency in nature. Rather than supposing the intervention of an external intelligent agent, this perspective suggests that the physical laws themselves, when interpreted through an informational lens, provide a kind of intrinsic “agency” that channels evolution toward increasing complexity and efficiency.

In the following sections, I will first review the theoretical foundations of information dynamics and its role in biological systems. Then, I will discuss the principles of non-equilibrium thermodynamics and how they inform our understanding of self-organization. Following this, ATP synthase will serve as a detailed case study demonstrating how a highly complex molecular machine might emerge from simple thermodynamic and information-theoretic principles. The discussion will then extend into the philosophical realm, where the notion of teleology and directed complexity is examined in the context of these scientific insights. Finally, the implications for evolutionary theory—and perhaps even for our broader understanding of life and intelligence—will be considered.

In doing so, this paper aims to provide a comprehensive view of how modern biophysical insights challenge and enrich our understanding of the evolutionary process, hinting at the possibility that nature itself might be predisposed toward complexity and order.

1. Foundations of Information Dynamics in Biological Systems

Understanding the emergence of complexity in biological systems requires a deep examination of the role of information. Information theory, originally developed by Claude Shannon, quantifies the amount of uncertainty present in a system. In physical and biological systems alike, information has become a central concept in understanding how complex structures arise and are maintained.

At the molecular level, the genetic code—which comprises sequences of nucleotides—represents structured information that has been built up and refined over billions of years. Every mutation, every gene duplication, and every recombination event contribute incrementally to the overall “message” encoded in an organism’s genome. In this view, evolution can be seen not simply as a series of random trials but as a complex computational process that sorts through vast possibilities to record the “successful” configurations that enhance survival.

A useful concept in this regard is Shannon entropy, which measures the uncertainty or randomness in information. High entropy indicates disorder, while low entropy implies a higher degree of order or information content. Within the vast mutational space where random events produce countless potential outcomes, the appearance of low entropy structures—those bearing concentrated and precise informational content—suggests that certain configurations are statistically favored under the right conditions.

Biological systems have evolved ways to reduce entropy locally while increasing it globally. For example, the genetic replication machinery, error-correction systems, and regulatory networks all function to maintain high fidelity in reproducing and transmitting critical information. These mechanisms are inherently information-theoretic: they work against the natural tendency toward randomness by encoding and preserving valuable, low-entropy information.

Furthermore, the concept of algorithmic complexity or Kolmogorov complexity offers another angle of analysis. Here, the complexity of a biological structure is quantified in terms of the length of the shortest possible description (or algorithm) that can generate that structure. ATP synthase, for example, might appear as a marvel of biological engineering because its precise function requires a detailed algorithm to describe how its subunits interact. When we view the evolution of such a system through the lens of algorithmic complexity, we see that the lowest complexity—or shortest description—corresponds to the most efficient solutions, which evolution may gravitate toward over time.

In summary, information dynamics provide a powerful explanatory framework for understanding how biological order arises from chaotic and high-entropy beginnings. The emergence of low-entropy, high-information structures such as ATP synthase in an ocean of genetic noise suggests not only that remarkable order can evolve, but that the laws of information play a central role in guiding this process. This sets the stage for integrating these ideas with thermodynamic principles—a synthesis that may offer insight into an inherent, natural teleology.

2. Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics and Self-Organization

Life, in all its forms, exists far from the thermodynamic equilibrium that characterizes inanimate matter in a closed system. Instead, living systems continuously exchange energy and matter with their surroundings, making them prime examples of non-equilibrium systems. The study of non-equilibrium thermodynamics has revealed that such systems are prone to self-organization; that is, under conditions of constant energy flux, matter can spontaneously form complex, ordered structures.

This concept was famously advanced by physicist Ilya Prigogine, who described dissipative structures—organized patterns that emerge in systems driven away from equilibrium. Such structures are maintained by the continuous input and dissipation of energy. For life, this means that energy flows (for example, through a chemical gradient) can induce and maintain complex arrangements even when the overall system is far from equilibrium.

One of the most intriguing proposals in this context is offered by Jeremy England’s hypothesis. England suggests that when matter is subject to a constant energy flux, it naturally reorganizes into states that optimize energy dissipation—states that, in many cases, are highly structured and complex. This reorganization is not guided by an external hand but arises directly from the thermodynamic imperative to dissipate energy as efficiently as possible.

England’s work is particularly compelling when considering molecular motors like ATP synthase. This enzyme operates in an environment characterized by a proton gradient—a form of stored potential energy generated by earlier metabolic processes. In dissipating this energy, ATP synthase converts the gradient into chemical energy stored in ATP. Remarkably, the molecular structure of ATP synthase appears exquisitely optimized for this process, minimizing energy loss and maximizing efficiency. Its very design—comprising a rotary mechanism that couples energy flow directly into mechanical motion and chemical synthesis—can be seen as a natural outcome of self-organizing dynamics under energy constraints.

The concept of energy dissipation can be further connected with entropy production. In classic thermodynamics, entropy is a measure of disorder. However, in non-equilibrium systems, entropy production is not merely a sign of randomness but can be a driver of order. When an open system like a cell is forced to continually process energy, it develops strategies to channel that energy into useful work. In evolutionary terms, organisms that efficiently dissipate energy while building and maintaining order are naturally selected for. Thus, rather than being a random collection of molecular mishaps, the emergence of ATP synthase and similar molecular systems may be an expression of an underlying tendency for matter to organize itself under non-equilibrium conditions.

Thus, non-equilibrium thermodynamics bridges a crucial gap between the seeming randomness of mutations and the reliable emergence of complex, low-entropy structures. It provides a universal framework that hints at a “directionality” inherent in physical processes—not in the sense of purposeful design—but as a natural consequence of energy flow. Systems like ATP synthase, which demonstrate maximal efficiency in energy conversion, reinforce this view. They signal that, given the right conditions, complex biological machines are not only possible but likely outcomes of the laws of physics.

3. ATP Synthase: A Paradigm of Complexity and Efficiency

ATP synthase offers one of the most compelling examples of a highly organized, efficient molecular machine emerging through evolutionary processes. This enzyme is responsible for the synthesis of adenosine triphosphate (ATP), the universal energy currency of the cell, and is found in every form of life—from bacteria to humans. Its widespread conservation across disparate life forms underscores a remarkable evolutionary history that can be examined from both a biochemical and thermodynamic standpoint.

Structurally, ATP synthase is composed of two main components: the F₀ domain, embedded within the membrane, and the F₁ domain, which protrudes into the cytoplasm (or mitochondrial matrix in eukaryotes). The F₀ domain forms a channel through which protons flow, driven by a gradient established by cellular respiration or photosynthesis. This proton movement induces a rotation within the enzyme’s structure—a rotary mechanism that is translated into mechanical work. The F₁ domain then uses this rotational energy to catalyze the formation of ATP from adenosine diphosphate (ADP) and inorganic phosphate.

Each step of the reaction is intricately coordinated. Notably, the enzyme’s ability to rotate like a turbine—converting potential energy locked in a proton gradient into the chemical energy of ATP—is one of its most striking features. If any one of the successive steps or components of ATP synthase were to fail, the entire enzyme would cease to function. This “all-or-nothing” nature has made the enzyme a poster child for the concept of irreducible complexity, a point often raised in debates about intelligent design. However, when viewed through the lens of non-equilibrium thermodynamics and information dynamics, this very complexity becomes a testament to the inherent capacity of matter to self-organize and optimize under energy constraints.

Looking at ATP synthase through an evolutionary lens, the enzyme appears as the end result of incremental modifications over billions of years. Early versions of the enzyme may have been simpler proton pumps that lacked the full rotational mechanism. Over time, as the environmental conditions changed and as additional layers of regulation and efficiency became advantageous, these simpler systems were co-opted and refined to produce the modern, highly efficient enzyme. Each incremental modification, while often individually deleterious, was eventually fine-tuned in a context where an efficient energy conversion mechanism was favored by the underlying thermodynamic imperatives.

The low-entropy state of ATP synthase is particularly noteworthy. In a vast mutational landscape where random changes frequently result in nonfunctional or less efficient molecular forms, the emergence of a highly ordered state represents an island of information density. This ordering implies a self-selection of molecular configurations that are best suited for efficient energy conversion amidst widespread disorder. In information-theoretic terms, ATP synthase can be seen as encoding a significant amount of highly specific information—a “solution” that has been distilled from an enormous set of possibilities.

Furthermore, the faculty of ATP synthase to operate as a true molecular motor reinforces the notion of directed complexity. Its design allows for maximal energy harvest from environmental gradients, which not only sustains cellular life but also perpetuates the cycle of low-entropy information storage and processing. In doing so, ATP synthase embodies the principle that efficient information processing is inherently linked with energy dynamics—a theme central to the emerging field of information thermodynamics.

In practical terms, the efficiency of ATP synthase has inspired biomimetic approaches in nanotechnology and synthetic biology. Researchers are working to develop artificial systems that mimic the enzyme’s function, further underscoring the idea that given the right non-equilibrium conditions, nature’s design principles are not merely accidents but rather predictable outcomes. These endeavors emphasize that the evolution of such intricate machinery is consistent with the idea that systems naturally progress toward states of optimized energy and information flow.

Thus, ATP synthase is not just an evolutionary marvel; it is a tangible example of how complex order can emerge from the interplay of thermodynamic imperatives and information dynamics. Its intricate design, honed to perfection through the relentless pressure of natural selection and the inexorable drive toward energy dissipation, reinforces the hypothesis that nature may inherently favor the formation of such low-entropy, information-rich structures.

4. Teleology, Directed Complexity, and Emergent Order

The emergence of highly ordered systems from a backdrop of randomness has long fueled philosophical debates on teleology. Traditionally, teleological arguments in biology have invoked the idea of a purposeful design. However, the modern interpretation of teleology in a scientific context eschews supernatural explanations in favor of understanding how natural processes might inherently be predisposed toward complexity.

When we speak of teleology in this context, we are not necessarily implying the presence of an external designer; rather, we are asking whether the fundamental laws of physics—particularly those that govern energy flow and information—can themselves act as intrinsic “agents” that shape the course of evolution. The evidence from ATP synthase, and related molecular machines, suggests that evolution may indeed exhibit a form of directed complexity.

One provocative idea is that the very structure of the universe imposes constraints and directionalities on the emergence of complexity. Under non-equilibrium conditions, as discussed earlier, matter absorbs and dissipates energy, leading to spontaneous self-organization. This phenomenon is not chaotic but statistically biased toward configurations that efficiently manage energy flows. In other words, the pathways that lead to higher order and lower entropy are statistically favored when energy gradients exist. Such a view reframes the evolutionary process: rather than being an entirely accidental series of events, evolution might be seen as the unfolding of a natural tendency toward self-organization—a process that in effect “chooses” the most energy-efficient and information-rich configurations.

Consider the implications for molecular machines like ATP synthase. The enzyme’s remarkably ordered structure and profound energetic efficiency might be viewed as the inevitable outcome of a system driven to maximize energy dissipation. In such circumstances, the emergence of ATP synthase is not a fluke, but rather a statistically favored event in a universe where energy gradients and information processing guide the ordering of matter. In this light, teleology becomes a natural consequence of physical law—a built-in bias of the universe toward producing conditions that enable the emergence of complexity.

Moreover, when we incorporate information theory into this picture, the concept of directed complexity gains further ground. Biological evolution is not simply a story of random nucleotide substitutions; it is also the story of information accumulation. The low-entropy configurations seen in structures like ATP synthase represent peaks in an otherwise rugged information landscape. These are the configurations that encode high levels of informational content—an indication that they have been “selected” not merely by chance, but by their inherent capacity to process and store information efficiently.

Such a synthesis of thermodynamics and information theory suggests that the arrow of evolution may be partially “directed” by fundamental principles that favor order over randomness in certain contexts. This view bridges classical Darwinian evolution and emergent teleology. While Darwin’s mechanism of natural selection remains indispensable, it may be nested within a broader set of physical principles that predispose matter to evolve in ways that maximize energy efficiency and information capacity. In other words, while mutations and randomness initiate the journey, the terrain of physical law channels these effects toward ordered, low-entropy outcomes.

This perspective aligns well with the growing body of work on self-organized criticality and complex adaptive systems. In networks ranging from the neuronal circuits of the brain to the intricate interplay of ecological systems, we observe that certain dynamics are scale-invariant and appear to “self-tune” to critical thresholds where order and chaos coexist. Within these sweet spots, small perturbations can cascade into large-scale changes, but the overall system retains an underlying order. Applied to evolution, this suggests that while there are countless failures along the way, the very structure of the mutational space contains valleys of low entropy—regions where complexity and information are concentrated.

Philosophically, this convergence of ideas invites us to reconsider the traditional boundaries between chance and purpose. In this modern framework, purpose is not the domain of a supernatural planner but an emergent property of physical laws interacting with environmental constraints. The fact that ATP synthase, among other molecular machines, straddles this boundary offers tantalizing evidence that the emergence of life may be guided by an “implicit teleology” embedded within the fabric of nature itself.

This emergent teleology does not detract from the power of natural selection. Instead, it enriches our understanding of evolution by illuminating the hidden forces that bias the process toward certain outcomes. Rather than viewing the evolutionary process as a neutral, purely random walk, we can appreciate it as a constrained exploration of possibilities—a search through a landscape of energy and information that naturally favors configurations capable of coalescing into highly ordered systems.

5. Interplay of Information, Entropy, and Molecular Machines

Delving further into the interplay between information dynamics and entropy, we arrive at a synthesis that may help explain the evolution of molecular machines. In this framework, the balance between disorder (entropy) and order (information) is not merely a random tug-of-war—it is a dynamic equilibrium modulated by external energy flows and intrinsic structural constraints.

From an information theory perspective, biological systems are constantly encoding, transmitting, and decoding information. DNA, RNA, proteins—each of these components represents a message, and their interactions form the basis of cellular function. However, encoding such a message requires that the system overcome the natural drift toward disorder. In the absence of energy input and regulatory mechanisms, the information encoded in biological macromolecules would eventually degrade into randomness. It is here that non-equilibrium thermodynamics plays a crucial role by providing a continuous energy supply that helps maintain the low-entropy states required for life.

Consider the example of ATP synthase once more. The enzyme operates within membranes that are biochemically active environments. Proton gradients, maintained by upstream processes such as the electron transport chain, represent a constant inflow of energy. ATP synthase leverages this energy to drive the synthesis of ATP—a conversion process that can be interpreted through the lens of both information theory and thermodynamics. The enzyme’s rotational mechanism translates directional energy flow into a mechanically coordinated and information-rich process. Every complete rotation lowers the system’s entropy by converting disorganized proton energy into a highly ordered and useful chemical bond in ATP.

It is instructive to apply the metaphor of a computational algorithm here. Imagine evolution as a search algorithm operating in an astronomically vast space of possible molecular configurations. Most “iterations” of this algorithm yield nonfunctional or suboptimal results—these are the high-entropy outputs. However, when the system stumbles upon a configuration that not only functions but is also energetically efficient (a state of lower entropy and high informational content), that design is reinforced by natural selection. Over time, this feedback loop produces molecular machines that appear finely tuned to their role. ATP synthase, with its highly ordered structure and efficient energy transduction, stands out as one such peak in the evolutionary landscape.

The dual role of energy and information is further underscored by modern computational models that simulate evolutionary processes. Algorithms inspired by natural selection—commonly referred to as evolutionary algorithms—demonstrate that, given enough time and iterations, systems can develop surprisingly efficient solutions to complex problems. These simulations often reveal that while the majority of iterations produce failures or suboptimal designs, the landscape of potential solutions is not uniformly random. Instead, there exist “basins of attraction”—regions in the search space where the interplay of energy efficiency and information processing conspire to produce low-entropy, high-order configurations. ATP synthase may be viewed as an outcome of such evolutionary attractors in nature’s rugged fitness landscape.

Additionally, the free energy principle, advanced in various forms by neuroscientists and physicists alike, provides another viewpoint on how living systems maintain low-entropy states. In this framework, systems that minimize their free energy—that is, they reduce the difference between their internal state and the external environment—are more likely to persist and adapt. This principle dovetails neatly with the idea that life itself, including the construction of molecular machines, is an emergent strategy for efficiently processing energy and information. The remarkable performance of ATP synthase is then not a miraculous occurrence, but rather an emergent state that arises from the interplay of these fundamental principles.

Overall, the interplay between information, entropy, and energy in molecular systems suggests a natural bias toward the emergence of complexity. This understanding helps bridge the gap between molecular biology, thermodynamics, and information theory. It also opens the door to a reinterpretation of teleology in a natural context: the idea that the universe, by virtue of its physical laws, is predisposed to generate ordered, efficient structures.

6. Implications for Evolutionary Theory and Beyond

If we accept the view that fundamental thermodynamic and informational laws bias the outcome of evolutionary processes, the implications for evolutionary theory are profound. Rather than considering evolution as a purely stochastic process, we may begin to see it as a guided search—one where the landscape itself is shaped by underlying physical imperatives.

For instance, the conventional model of evolution emphasizes random mutations away from equilibrium states, with natural selection weeding out the suboptimal variants. However, if low-entropy, high-information configurations are statistically favored in systems driven by constant energy flows, then it follows that the probability of reaching such configurations might be higher than if all outcomes were truly random. In this view, the emergence of complex machinery such as ATP synthase becomes not an extremely low-probability fluke, but rather an expected outcome of the system’s intrinsic tendency to self-organize under energetic constraints.

Beyond biology, this perspective might have profound implications for our understanding of complexity throughout nature. It suggests that the same principles that drive the efficiency of ATP synthase might also apply to other systems—ranging from the formation of galaxies to the development of cognitive architectures in neural networks. In this sense, the emergence of directed complexity could be a universal phenomenon.

In practical terms, acknowledging a natural teleology embedded within evolutionary processes could inform new approaches to synthetic biology and nanotechnology. By understanding the fundamental drivers of self-organization, researchers might be better equipped to design artificial systems that mimic the efficiency of natural biological machines. This could lead to breakthroughs where engineered systems become more adaptive, robust, and energy efficient—mirroring the emergent properties observed in living organisms.

Philosophically, the idea that evolution is partially “directed” by the principles of energy dissipation and information processing invites us to reframe our notions of agency and purpose in the universe. While this approach does not ascribe consciousness or intent to physical laws, it does suggest that the emergence of structure and complexity is built into the fabric of reality. The universe may not be “intelligent” in the conventional sense, but it could nonetheless be seen as having an intrinsic capacity to generate order from chaos—a perspective that enriches our understanding of both life and the cosmos.

This line of inquiry also opens up new avenues for interdisciplinary research. The convergence of non-equilibrium thermodynamics, information theory, and evolutionary biology might eventually help us answer some of the most profound questions about life’s origins and its inevitable progression toward complexity. Could this trajectory ultimately lead to the emergence of intelligence, self-awareness, or even novel forms of life in environments far removed from our own? These are questions that not only challenge our scientific paradigms but also our philosophical and existential beliefs.

Conclusion

The interplay of information dynamics and non-equilibrium thermodynamics provides a compelling framework for reinterpreting the evolutionary emergence of complex molecular systems such as ATP synthase. Rather than relying solely on the traditional model of random mutation followed by natural selection, this perspective suggests that the fundamental laws governing energy flow and information processing impose directional pressures that bias evolution toward the emergence of low-entropy, high-efficiency structures.

ATP synthase stands as an exemplar of this phenomenon—a molecular machine whose highly ordered, intricately tuned design emerges as a natural result of the physical imperatives of energy dissipation. The enzyme’s evolutionary history, when viewed through the twin lenses of thermodynamics and information dynamics, hints at an emergent teleology where the universe’s inherent properties favor the evolution of order and complexity.

This synthesis of ideas does not invoke an external designer, but rather suggests that the structure of the mutational landscape is itself non-random. It is sculpted by constraints and attractors that favor efficient energy conversion and the accumulation of information. As such, the emergence of complexity in biological systems can be seen as an inevitable consequence of the interplay between entropy and information—a profound notion that blurs the distinction between chance and necessity.

Looking ahead, embracing the concepts of emergent teleology and directed complexity not only reshapes our understanding of biological evolution but also influences the way we design technology, interpret natural phenomena, and even approach philosophical questions about the nature of life and intelligence. In the grand tapestry of nature, the evolution of complex structures from the raw ingredients of chaos and energy appears less as a series of isolated accidents and more as a continuous, directed unfolding—a process that may well be woven into the very fabric of the universe.

References (Indicative)

While this paper is a synthesis of broad interdisciplinary research, key influences include:

• Prigogine, I. (1977). Dissipative Structures and Irreversible Processes.
• England, J. L. (2015). Statistical Physics of Self-Replication.
• Shannon, C. E. (1948). A Mathematical Theory of Communication.
• Additional perspectives from the fields of evolutionary biology, information theory, and non-equilibrium thermodynamics.

In conclusion, exploring evolution through the prism of information dynamics and thermodynamics reveals layers of order that suggest nature is predisposed toward complexity. This interplay not only challenges the notion of pure randomness in evolution but also holds promise for unifying disparate fields into a coherent narrative of the emergence of life—a narrative in which molecular machines like ATP synthase stand as silent witnesses to the directed, efficient, and awe-inspiring properties of the universe.